Six Sigma vs Lean Six Sigma: Which Certification to Choose?

What Is Six Sigma?

Six Sigma is a methodology grounded in data and statistics, designed to eliminate defects and elevate quality across various processes. Its primary goal is to pinpoint and eradicate the root causes of errors and defects in both manufacturing and business operations, thereby minimizing variability and enhancing consistency. This approach employs a comprehensive suite of quality management techniques, notably statistical methods, and establishes a dedicated cadre of in-house experts.

The objective of Six Sigma is to realize a process efficiency where the output is virtually defect-free, achieving a remarkable standard of 99.99966% precision, or 3.4 defects per million opportunities (DPMO). Six Sigma initiatives are guided by two principal methodologies that draw inspiration from Deming's Plan-Do-Check-Act Cycle: DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control) is applied to enhance existing processes, while DMADV, an acronym for Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, and Verify, is used in the development of new products or process designs.

What Is Lean?

It is a systematic approach to process improvement focusing on minimizing waste and maximizing value in organizational processes. Lean methodology aims to streamline operations, enhance product quality, and improve efficiency by identifying and eliminating non-value-added activities. It employs tools and techniques such as 5S, Kanban, Value Stream Mapping, and Just-In-Time (JIT) production.

Lean seeks to optimize workflow, reduce lead times, and build more value for the customer base with fewer resources. At its core, Lean is not just about cutting costs but about developing a culture of continuous improvement, in which every employee is engaged in spotting inefficiencies and contributing to a more effective and agile process.

What Is Lean Six Sigma?

Lean Six Sigma is a data-driven, fact-based improvement concept prioritizing defect prevention over defect detection. It improves customer satisfaction and bottom-line results by lowering variation, waste, and cycle time while encouraging the use of work standardization and flow, resulting in a competitive advantage. It applies wherever there is variation and waste; every employee should be involved.

Lean vs Six Sigma: Similarities and Differences

Lean and Six Sigma aim to improve business processes but approach them from slightly different perspectives and methodologies. Combining both (Lean Six Sigma) leverages the strengths of each to maximize value by reducing waste, improving process speed, and eliminating defects.

Lean and Six Sigma: Similarities

Aspect	Lean	Six Sigma	Similarities
Focus	Eliminating waste to streamline processes and reduce costs.	Reducing variation and defects to improve quality.	Both improve business processes and increase efficiency.
Goal	Maximize value for the customer by removing non-value-adding activities.	Achieve stable and predictable results by minimizing process variation.	Enhance customer satisfaction by improving quality and efficiency.
Methodology	Uses tools like value stream mapping, 5S, Kanban, and JIT.	Utilizes DMAIC  or DMADV frameworks.	Both methodologies rely on a structured approach to problem-solving.
Performance Metrics	Focuses on cycle time, lead time, process speed, and efficiency.	Concentrates on statistical measures to identify and reduce defects.	Both seek to measure and improve the performance.
Culture	Encourages a culture of continuous improvement and respect for people.	Promotes a culture of quality and precision through statistical analysis.	Both foster an organizational culture for improvement.
Application	Often applied in manufacturing, but also in services and other sectors.	Widely used in manufacturing, healthcare, finance, etc.	Both are adaptable and applied across industries to improve processes.
Outcome	Improved process flow and efficiency, reduced waste, and lower costs.	Improved product quality, reduced defects, and user satisfaction.	Both result in enhanced operational efficiency and better outputs.

Lean and Six Sigma: Differences

Aspect	Lean	Six Sigma
Focus	Eliminating waste and improving flow	Reducing variation and eliminating defects
Goal	Increase speed and efficiency of processes	Improve quality and precision of processes
Approach	Streamlining processes by removing non-value-added activities	Using statistical methods to identify and remove causes of defects
Origin	Originated from the Toyota Production System in the early 20th century	Developed in 1980s by Motorola and popularized by General Electric in the 1990s
Tools	5S, Kaizen, Value Stream Mapping, JIT (Just-In-Time)	DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control), DMADV (Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, Verify)
Metrics	Lead time, Cycle time, Takt time	DPMO (Defects Per Million Opportunities), Sigma level
Implementation	Focuses on continuous flow and pulling only what is needed from the previous step	Focuses on rigorous data collection and analysis to identify root causes of defects
Outcome	Reduction in waste, improved workflow and efficiency	Reduced process variation, enhanced quality, and increased customer satisfaction
Philosophy	Based on the principle of creating more value for the customer with less work	Based on the principle of making processes more uniform and predictable

What Is Lean Six Sigma?

Lean Six Sigma is a synergistic business strategy that combines two powerful methodologies: Lean, which focuses on reducing waste and improving process flow to enhance speed and efficiency, and Six Sigma, which aims to reduce defects and variability in processes through rigorous statistical analysis. 

Integrating Lean's waste-reduction principles with Six Sigma's focus on quality improvement leads to a comprehensive approach that enables organizations to improve performance, customer satisfaction, and profitability significantly. Lean Six Sigma emphasizes continuous improvement, employing tools and techniques from both methodologies to streamline operations, increase quality, and reduce costs, making it a highly effective framework for organizational excellence.

Lean Six Sigma Certification Eligibilities, Examinations, and Responsibilities

Lean Six Sigma is a disciplined, data-driven approach and methodology for eliminating defects in any process. Lean Six Sigma certifications are designed to validate professionals' expertise on the Lean Six Sigma methodology, tools, and techniques.

1. Lean Six Sigma Green Belt

Course Link: Green Belt Certification

Eligibility

• Professionals with at least three years of full-time work experience are preferred.
• Experience in leading projects is beneficial but not mandatory.
• A basic understanding of Lean Six Sigma tools and principles is recommended.

Examination

• Typically consists of a multiple-choice exam.
• Exam duration varies but is usually around 2 to 3 hours.
• Covers topics such as the DMAIC process, basic Lean principles, and the use of specific Lean Six Sigma tools.

Roles and Responsibilities

• Lead and manage small-scale Lean Six Sigma projects within their work area.
• Serve as a support for complex projects led by a Black Belt.
• Analyze and solve quality problems.
• Participate in process improvement initiatives.

2. Lean Six Sigma Black Belt

Course Link: Black Belt Certification

Eligibility

• Requires a Green Belt certification or a comparable level of knowledge.
• Recommended to have at least three to five years of work experience in a role that involves process improvement.
• Leadership experience with proven project management skills.

Examination

• More comprehensive than the Green Belt exam, often including essay questions in addition to multiple-choice.
• Duration is typically 4 hours or more.
• Examines a deeper knowledge of Lean Six Sigma principles, including advanced tools and techniques, project management, and team leadership.

Roles and Responsibilities

• Lead complex Lean Six Sigma projects at an organizational level.
• Train and mentor Green Belts and other team members.
• Develop strategies for process improvement and quality assurance.
• Interface with all levels of management to ensure project goals are aligned with organizational objectives.

3. Lean Six Sigma Certification

Course: Lean Six Sigma Masters

Eligibility

• A Lean Six Sigma Black Belt certification or equivalent experience and knowledge.
• More than 5 years of experience leading and managing Lean Six Sigma projects and initiatives.
• A portfolio of successful projects that show significant, quantifiable improvements.
• Experience in training, mentoring, and coaching other Lean Six Sigma practitioners is usually required.

Examination

• A comprehensive written test that covers advanced topics in Lean Six Sigma methodologies, strategic implementation, and change management.
• Submit documentation of one or more Lean Six Sigma projects, demonstrating the ability to apply advanced principles.
• Some certifying organizations include an interview process to assess the understanding and experience in Lean Six Sigma at an expert level.

Roles and Responsibilities

• Set the strategic direction of Lean Six Sigma programs within the organization.
• Deploy Lean Six Sigma methodologies across the organization.
• Develop and deliver Lean Six Sigma training programs.
• Provide oversight, guidance, and support to high-impact projects.

Boost your career path as a skilled quality management expert with our Lean Six Sigma Expert Training aligned with the LSS-Green Belt and Black Belt certification from IASSC. Contact us and get ahead in your career right away!

Which Is Right for You?

The best methodology for your organization hinges on its unique needs. Six Sigma could be the ideal approach if your organization aims to minimize variability and risk within a complex setting. On the other hand, if your organization is looking for a straightforward, continuous method to guide innovation and improvement, Lean might be the better choice. While some organizations adopt one of these methodologies exclusively, others opt to blend both approaches to align with their operational goals.

Elevate your professional journey with Simplilearn's Lean Six Sigma Expert Master's Program. This comprehensive course is meticulously designed to transform you into a skilled practitioner proficient in the art of improving quality, efficiency, and performance in any business process. By blending the waste-reducing principles of Lean with the defect-minimization techniques of Six Sigma, this program offers a dual approach to operational excellence.

Additionally, explore Simplilearn's informative "What is Six Sigma?" video for a clearer understanding and insight.

Learn for free! Subscribe to our YouTube Channel & Be a Part of 400k+ Happy Learners Community.

FAQs

1. What comes first, Six Sigma or Lean?

Six Sigma and Lean are different methodologies and can be implemented in any order based on an organization's specific needs and goals.

2. What are the two types of Six Sigma?

The two types of Six Sigma are DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) and DMADV (Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, Verify).

3. What is the difference between Six Sigma and Lean Six Sigma?

Six Sigma is a quality management methodology that aims to reduce defects and improve process efficiency through data-driven problem-solving and statistical analysis. Lean Six Sigma combines the principles of Six Sigma with Lean manufacturing, which aims to eliminate waste and streamline processes to increase efficiency and improve customer value. In other words, Lean Six Sigma incorporates the problem-solving approach of Six Sigma with a focus on continuous improvement and error reduction.

4. Which is better: Six Sigma or Lean?

It depends on the specific needs and goals of an organization. Both Six Sigma and Lean have their strengths and can be used to achieve different outcomes.

Six Sigma focuses on reducing defects and improving process efficiency through data-driven problem-solving and statistical analysis, making it well-suited for organizations looking to improve the quality of their products or services.

Lean, on the other hand, focuses on streamlining processes and eliminating waste to increase efficiency and improve customer value, making it well-suited for organizations looking to increase their competitiveness and profitability.

In some cases, combining the two approaches, as in Lean Six Sigma green belt, can lead to even greater results. It's recommended to assess the specific needs and goals of the organization and choose the approach that best fits those needs.